Circumcision Myths vs. Facts: Separating Truth From Misinformation

Posted on Mar. 3rd, 2025

When it comes to circumcision, there is no shortage of opinions, stories, and—unfortunately—misinformation. Parents and individuals considering the procedure often come across conflicting information, making it difficult to know what’s true and what’s simply a myth. Some believe circumcision is purely cosmetic, while others think it’s painful and risky. The reality is that circumcision is a safe, common, and time-tested procedure when performed by an experienced professional. By addressing common myths with clear, factual information, we aim to help families feel confident and well-informed about their decision.

Misinformation can lead to unnecessary concerns and confusion, so it’s important to separate fact from fiction. In this guide, we’ll debunk some of the most common myths about circumcision, covering topics like pain management, health benefits, religious considerations, and healing times. Whether you’re a new parent, an adult considering the procedure, or simply looking for accurate, professional insight, this post will give you the answers you need.

Circumcision Is Only Done for Religious Reasons

One of the biggest misconceptions about circumcision is that it’s exclusively a religious practice. While it holds deep cultural and spiritual significance in Judaism and Islam, circumcision is also widely performed for medical, personal, and hygienic reasons. Many families choose the procedure for health benefits, cleanliness, and potential future advantages rather than religious traditions. In fact, circumcision is common worldwide among families of all backgrounds, including those with no religious affiliation at all. It is simply a personal choice that parents and individuals make based on what they feel is best.

The medical community recognizes circumcision as a valid and beneficial procedure, regardless of religious context. Many pediatricians, urologists, and healthcare professionals recommend circumcision for its potential to reduce infections, improve hygiene, and lower certain health risks. It is performed in hospitals, clinics, and specialized practices, offering a safe, medically sound option for families who choose it. Religion is just one of many reasons people opt for circumcision, but it is by no means the only one.

Circumcision Is Extremely Painful

One of the most frequent concerns parents have is whether circumcision is a painful experience for their baby. The truth is, when performed by a skilled provider, circumcision is quick and nearly painless. A local anesthetic is used to numb the area, ensuring that the baby feels little to no discomfort during the procedure. Additionally, the Mogen Shield technique we use allows for a fast and efficient circumcision, minimizing stress and discomfort for the infant. In reality, most babies cry more from being undressed or held in position than from the procedure itself.

After the circumcision, babies are typically calm and able to nurse or bottle-feed immediately. Any mild discomfort is temporary and easily managed with ointment and proper care. Unlike outdated methods that might have caused prolonged discomfort, our approach ensures quick healing and minimal irritation. Parents are often surprised at how quickly and smoothly their baby recovers, with many showing no signs of distress shortly after the procedure.

Circumcision Has No Medical Benefits

Some claim that circumcision offers no health benefits, but medical research tells a different story. Studies have shown that circumcision can help reduce the risk of urinary tract infections (UTIs) in infants, which can be serious in young babies. Additionally, circumcised males have a lower lifetime risk of certain sexually transmitted infections (STIs), including HIV, due to the removal of foreskin tissue that can harbor bacteria and viruses. These long-term health benefits make circumcision a practical choice for many families.

Beyond infection prevention, circumcision can also help reduce issues like phimosis, a condition where the foreskin becomes too tight and causes pain or difficulty with hygiene. Poor hygiene in uncircumcised males can lead to inflammation and infections, particularly in later years. While proper care and cleanliness can help mitigate some risks, circumcision provides a lifelong reduction in certain health concerns.

Circumcision Takes a Long Time to Heal

Healing time is one of the easiest parts of the circumcision process. Many parents assume that recovery is long and difficult, but in reality, newborns heal incredibly fast. The procedure itself takes under a minute, and within a few days, the majority of healing is complete. Most babies show no signs of discomfort after the first 24–48 hours, and full healing typically occurs within a week.

We provide parents with clear, simple aftercare instructions to make sure everything goes smoothly. By applying ointment regularly and keeping the area clean, healing happens naturally and with minimal irritation. Unlike some older circumcision methods that involve plastic rings or prolonged healing devices, our approach ensures a fast and easy recovery. Parents are often relieved at how effortless the healing process is, with babies quickly returning to their normal routine.

Circumcision Is Risky and Unsafe

Any medical procedure carries some level of risk, but when performed by an experienced professional, circumcision is one of the safest minor procedures available. Complications are rare, especially when done by a trained and specialized provider. Our technique uses a gentle, precise approach that minimizes bleeding, discomfort, and potential complications. In fact, circumcision performed in a specialized setting has a higher safety rate than hospital-based circumcisions, which often use less refined techniques.

We take every precaution to ensure a smooth, safe experience, using sterile instruments and best practices at every step. Our expertise ensures that each circumcision is done efficiently and correctly, reducing the chances of any complications or unnecessary discomfort. Parents can feel fully confident knowing their baby is in the hands of a provider with years of experience and training.

Adults Can’t Get Circumcised

While newborn circumcision is most common, circumcision is still a safe and beneficial option for older children, teens, and adults. Many individuals choose to undergo the procedure later in life for medical, personal, or religious reasons. Whether due to hygiene concerns, health benefits, or lifestyle choices, adult circumcision is a common and straightforward procedure.

The procedure for adults is done under local anesthesia, ensuring a pain-free experience. While healing takes slightly longer than for infants, most adults are back to normal activities within a couple of weeks. We work closely with patients to provide clear guidance, support, and aftercare instructions to ensure a smooth recovery process.

Book a Consultation Today

Circumcision is a personal decision, and understanding the facts can help you feel confident about making the right choice for you or your child. While myths and misinformation can create unnecessary concerns, the reality is that circumcision is a safe, simple, and beneficial procedure when performed by an experienced provider. From reducing health risks and improving hygiene to ensuring quick healing and minimal discomfort, the benefits are clear.

If you’re considering circumcision and want trusted, expert care, we’re here to help. Call Arizona Circumcision today at (602) 592-6717 to schedule a consultation and get all the information you need from professionals who specialize in safe, precise, and compassionate circumcision services.